Tweet
Some questions have no right answer. Tabs vs spaces. Best programming language. Whether hot dogs are sandwiches. These debates are eternal, passionate, and mostly pointless—which makes them perfect.
This is where we argue about opinions, run polls, debate preferences, and generally disagree in friendly ways. Not serious fights—playful arguments about things that don't really matter but we all have opinions on anyway.
Why Debates Matter
Arguing about inconsequential things is community bonding. You learn how people think, what they value, how they reason. Plus it's fun.
Polls reveal community preferences. What tools do people actually use? What problems do they face? What do they care about?
Debates sharpen thinking. Defending your position, considering counterarguments, changing your mind when you're wrong—these are valuable skills.
Good Debate Topics
Tech preferences: Programming languages, frameworks, tools, platforms. These inspire passionate defense.
Methodology debates: Agile vs waterfall, TDD vs not, microservices vs monolith. Different contexts need different approaches, but we'll argue anyway.
Naming and conventions: Camel case vs snake case, tabs vs spaces, where to put braces. Holy wars over trivial things.
Industry trends: Is X overhyped? Will Y replace Z? What's the next big thing?
Hypotheticals: Would you rather debug or write docs? Code or manage? Work at startup or big tech?
Debate Guidelines
Stay friendly: Disagree about ideas, not people. "I prefer X because Y" not "Only idiots use Z."
Acknowledge context matters: "It depends" is valid answer. What works for you might not work for others.
Change your mind when convinced: Admitting you're wrong is strength, not weakness.
Don't take it personally: Someone criticizing your favorite tool isn't criticizing you.
Have fun: If debate stops being fun, stop debating.
Classic Holy Wars
Tabs vs Spaces
The eternal war. Both sides convinced they're objectively right.
Truth: Spaces won in most communities. But tabs people won't surrender.
Stack Overflow survey tracks this annually. Spaces ahead.
Vim vs Emacs vs VS Code
Old guard: Vim and Emacs loyalists with decades of muscle memory New guard: VS Code with its extensions and ease of use Dark horse: Neovim with Lua configuration
Reality: Most people use VS Code. Modal editing fans use Vim/Neovim. Emacs users are unshakeable.
Light Theme vs Dark Theme
Dark theme users: "How do you use light theme without burning your retinas?" Light theme users: "Dark theme in daylight is unreadable"
Truth: Use what works for your environment. Both sides convinced they're superior.
Programming Language Wars
JavaScript: "Runs everywhere!" vs "typeof null === 'object'" Python: "Readable and simple!" vs "Whitespace as syntax what were they thinking" Rust: "Memory safe!" vs "Takes 20 minutes to compile hello world" Go: "Simple and fast!" vs "Error handling is painful" TypeScript: "JavaScript but type-safe!" vs "Complex type gymnastics"
All languages have tradeoffs. We argue anyway.
Best IDE
VS Code, JetBrains IDEs, Vim, Emacs, Sublime, Atom (RIP), Notepad++ (yes really).
Each has passionate defenders. VS Code won market share. Others serve specific needs.
MacOS vs Linux vs Windows
Mac users: Premium experience, it just works Linux users: Total control, customizable, free Windows users: Gaming and compatibility
Everyone's defensive about their choice because we spend all day on these systems.
Running Polls
Want community input? Create polls:
Tool preferences: "What do you use for X?" Problems encountered: "What's your biggest challenge with Y?" Interest checks: "Would you use Z if it existed?" Predictions: "What tech will be big in 2025?"
Poll platforms:
Reddit native polls (if cross-posting) Twitter/X polls (limited options, 24hr max) StrawPoll - Simple, free, shareable Pollly for Slack - If community has Slack Google Forms for complex surveys
Debate Formats
Quick take: One-sentence opinion, others respond
Detailed argument: Lay out full reasoning with examples
Devil's advocate: Argue position you don't hold to explore other side
Hypothetical: "Would you rather..." scenarios
Predictions: Make predictions, revisit later to see who was right
Keeping Debates Healthy
Avoid actual sensitive topics: Politics, religion, inflammatory social issues. Not the place.
Call out toxicity: If debate turns mean, step in. Community polices itself.
Know when to agree to disagree: Some debates have no resolution. That's fine.
Appreciate good arguments: Even if you disagree, recognize well-reasoned positions.
Making Productive Arguments
State your position clearly Provide reasoning and examples Acknowledge valid counterpoints Explain why you still prefer your position Be open to changing your mind
Bad argument: "X sucks, Y is better" Good argument: "I prefer Y over X because [specific reasons], though I understand X works well for [specific use cases]"
Fun Hypotheticals
Would you rather:
No right answers. Reveals values and priorities.
Prediction Debates
Make predictions, track them, revisit later:
"AI will replace X jobs by Y year" "Z framework will be dead in 2 years" "Blockchain will finally find use case in..." "Remote work is permanent" vs "Back to office will win"
Being wrong is fine. Being certain is suspicious. Best predictions admit uncertainty.
Resources
Change My View subreddit - Structured debates Kialo - Structured argument mapping
Argue about stuff that doesn't matter. Bond over disagreements. Remember it's all in good fun. The best debates are the ones where everyone learns something, even if nobody changes their mind.
This is where we argue about opinions, run polls, debate preferences, and generally disagree in friendly ways. Not serious fights—playful arguments about things that don't really matter but we all have opinions on anyway.
Why Debates Matter
Arguing about inconsequential things is community bonding. You learn how people think, what they value, how they reason. Plus it's fun.
Polls reveal community preferences. What tools do people actually use? What problems do they face? What do they care about?
Debates sharpen thinking. Defending your position, considering counterarguments, changing your mind when you're wrong—these are valuable skills.
Good Debate Topics
Tech preferences: Programming languages, frameworks, tools, platforms. These inspire passionate defense.
Methodology debates: Agile vs waterfall, TDD vs not, microservices vs monolith. Different contexts need different approaches, but we'll argue anyway.
Naming and conventions: Camel case vs snake case, tabs vs spaces, where to put braces. Holy wars over trivial things.
Industry trends: Is X overhyped? Will Y replace Z? What's the next big thing?
Hypotheticals: Would you rather debug or write docs? Code or manage? Work at startup or big tech?
Debate Guidelines
Stay friendly: Disagree about ideas, not people. "I prefer X because Y" not "Only idiots use Z."
Acknowledge context matters: "It depends" is valid answer. What works for you might not work for others.
Change your mind when convinced: Admitting you're wrong is strength, not weakness.
Don't take it personally: Someone criticizing your favorite tool isn't criticizing you.
Have fun: If debate stops being fun, stop debating.
Classic Holy Wars
Tabs vs Spaces
The eternal war. Both sides convinced they're objectively right.
Truth: Spaces won in most communities. But tabs people won't surrender.
Stack Overflow survey tracks this annually. Spaces ahead.
Vim vs Emacs vs VS Code
Old guard: Vim and Emacs loyalists with decades of muscle memory New guard: VS Code with its extensions and ease of use Dark horse: Neovim with Lua configuration
Reality: Most people use VS Code. Modal editing fans use Vim/Neovim. Emacs users are unshakeable.
Light Theme vs Dark Theme
Dark theme users: "How do you use light theme without burning your retinas?" Light theme users: "Dark theme in daylight is unreadable"
Truth: Use what works for your environment. Both sides convinced they're superior.
Programming Language Wars
JavaScript: "Runs everywhere!" vs "typeof null === 'object'" Python: "Readable and simple!" vs "Whitespace as syntax what were they thinking" Rust: "Memory safe!" vs "Takes 20 minutes to compile hello world" Go: "Simple and fast!" vs "Error handling is painful" TypeScript: "JavaScript but type-safe!" vs "Complex type gymnastics"
All languages have tradeoffs. We argue anyway.
Best IDE
VS Code, JetBrains IDEs, Vim, Emacs, Sublime, Atom (RIP), Notepad++ (yes really).
Each has passionate defenders. VS Code won market share. Others serve specific needs.
MacOS vs Linux vs Windows
Mac users: Premium experience, it just works Linux users: Total control, customizable, free Windows users: Gaming and compatibility
Everyone's defensive about their choice because we spend all day on these systems.
Running Polls
Want community input? Create polls:
Tool preferences: "What do you use for X?" Problems encountered: "What's your biggest challenge with Y?" Interest checks: "Would you use Z if it existed?" Predictions: "What tech will be big in 2025?"
Poll platforms:
Reddit native polls (if cross-posting) Twitter/X polls (limited options, 24hr max) StrawPoll - Simple, free, shareable Pollly for Slack - If community has Slack Google Forms for complex surveys
Debate Formats
Quick take: One-sentence opinion, others respond
Detailed argument: Lay out full reasoning with examples
Devil's advocate: Argue position you don't hold to explore other side
Hypothetical: "Would you rather..." scenarios
Predictions: Make predictions, revisit later to see who was right
Keeping Debates Healthy
Avoid actual sensitive topics: Politics, religion, inflammatory social issues. Not the place.
Call out toxicity: If debate turns mean, step in. Community polices itself.
Know when to agree to disagree: Some debates have no resolution. That's fine.
Appreciate good arguments: Even if you disagree, recognize well-reasoned positions.
Making Productive Arguments
State your position clearly Provide reasoning and examples Acknowledge valid counterpoints Explain why you still prefer your position Be open to changing your mind
Bad argument: "X sucks, Y is better" Good argument: "I prefer Y over X because [specific reasons], though I understand X works well for [specific use cases]"
Fun Hypotheticals
Would you rather:
- Write only frontend or only backend for a year?
- Debug legacy code or write documentation?
- Work on interesting problem with terrible stack or boring problem with great stack?
- Have unlimited budget with tight deadline or tiny budget with flexible timeline?
- Build something millions use that you hate or something 10 people use that you love?
No right answers. Reveals values and priorities.
Prediction Debates
Make predictions, track them, revisit later:
"AI will replace X jobs by Y year" "Z framework will be dead in 2 years" "Blockchain will finally find use case in..." "Remote work is permanent" vs "Back to office will win"
Being wrong is fine. Being certain is suspicious. Best predictions admit uncertainty.
Resources
Change My View subreddit - Structured debates Kialo - Structured argument mapping
Argue about stuff that doesn't matter. Bond over disagreements. Remember it's all in good fun. The best debates are the ones where everyone learns something, even if nobody changes their mind.